Prior Authorization in Healthcare: Complete Process Guide to Reduce Treatment Delays

Prior authorization has become the gatekeeper of modern healthcare. Insurance companies require approval before many treatments, procedures, and medications are provided. Yet the process remains one of the biggest frustrations for patients and providers alike, causing delays that can impact patient outcomes and clinical urgency.

This comprehensive guide breaks down the prior authorization process step-by-step, explains why it exists, identifies procedures that require authorization, and provides proven strategies to reduce approval delays. Whether you're a healthcare provider, billing professional, or patient advocate, understanding this process is critical for ensuring timely care.

What is Prior Authorization and Why Does It Exist?

Definition and Purpose

Prior authorization (also called prior approval, pre-authorization, or pre-approval) is a requirement by insurance companies to receive approval BEFORE providing certain healthcare services, procedures, medications, or treatments.

The insurance company reviews the request and either:

• Approves the service (authorization granted)
• Conditionally approves with limitations
• Denies the service (not covered or not medically necessary)
• Requests more information before deciding

Why Insurance Companies Require Prior Authorization

Insurance companies use prior authorization to:

1. Manage Costs

• Prevent unnecessary or overly expensive procedures
• Encourage use of less expensive alternatives
• Control utilization of high-cost services
• Negotiate volume discounts

2. Ensure Medical Necessity

• Verify the procedure/medication is appropriate for the diagnosis
• Prevent procedures not supported by clinical guidelines
• Reduce fraud and abuse
• Align with evidence-based medicine

3. Prevent Inappropriate Care

• Reduce surgical procedures that don't meet clinical criteria
• Prevent overtreatment
• Encourage conservative approaches first (less costly)
• Improve patient outcomes through guided care

4. Manage Network Providers

• Control where patients access care
• Ensure services are from contracted providers
• Manage facility utilization
• Track quality metrics for providers

Why Providers Complain About Prior Authorization

Despite the stated purpose, prior authorization creates significant operational challenges:

Administrative Burden:

• Average 20-30 minutes per authorization request
• Requires clinical staff time away from patient care
• Multiple payers with different requirements
• Manual processes (phone, fax, web portals)

Care Delays:

• Average approval time: 3-5 business days
• Urgent cases may take 24 hours
• Emergency care can't wait for authorization
• Some treatments lose efficacy if delayed

Denial Rates:

• Overall prior auth denial rate: 5-10%
• Cardiology: 10-15% denial rate
• Mental health: 15-20% denial rate
• Specialty procedures: 12-18% denial rate

Patient Impact:

• Delayed care causes clinical deterioration
• Patients defer needed treatment due to uncertainty
• Increased anxiety about cost/coverage
• Treatment outcomes affected by delays

The Controversy Around Prior Authorization

Medical organizations increasingly criticize prior authorization:

American Medical Association (AMA) Position:

• Prior auth creates "unacceptable administrative burden"
• Contributes to healthcare provider burnout
• Can delay necessary care
• Increases healthcare costs (admin overhead)

Proposed Reforms:

• Streamlined electronic prior authorization (ePA)
• Reduced documentation requirements
• Faster turnaround times (24-48 hours)
• Transparent coverage criteria
• Limited prior auth requirements

---

Understanding the Prior Authorization Landscape

Who Requires Prior Authorization?

Insurance Types Requiring Prior Auth:

1. Managed Care Plans (HMOs, PPOs)

• Most likely to require prior authorization
• Network management requirement
• Multiple prior auth requirements common

2. Medicare Advantage Plans

• Require prior auth for many services
• Vary by specific plan
• More restrictive than Original Medicare

3. Original Medicare (Fee-for-Service)

• Generally fewer prior auth requirements
• Limited National Coverage Determinations
• Local Coverage Determinations may require auth

4. Medicaid Plans

• Highly variable by state
• Often require prior auth for expensive procedures
• Pharmacy requirements common

5. Commercial Insurance Plans

• Most restrictive for prior authorization
• Frequent requirements across many services
• Highest denial rates

Important: Not all services require prior authorization. Common non-authorized services include:

• Office visits (usually)
• Preventive care (usually)
• Emergency care (retroactive auth only)
• Routine lab tests (usually)
• Basic imaging (sometimes auth required)

---

The Prior Authorization Process: Step-by-Step

Understanding the complete process helps you navigate it efficiently.

STEP 1: Determine if Prior Authorization is Required

How to Check:

Method 1: Insurance Benefit Documents

• Review plan's Summary of Benefits and Coverage (SBC)
• Check plan website's authorization requirements
• Call insurance customer service line
• Note: Not always 100% accurate; may have updates

Method 2: Provider Resources

• Check your practice's authorization matrix by payer
• Reference your billing software's prior auth module
• Ask your insurance liaison/representative
• Review recent authorization patterns with same payer

Method 3: Direct Payer Inquiry

• Call insurance authorization department
• Have patient's ID number and DOB ready
• Confirm specific procedure/medication requiring auth
• Document confirmation in patient record
• Get authorization requirements

Red Flag Procedures (Often Require Auth):

• Advanced imaging (MRI, CT, PET scans)
• Surgical procedures (especially orthopedic, cardiac)
• Mental health services (especially intensive)
• Specialty medications (especially biologics)
• Durable medical equipment (DME)
• Home health and rehabilitation services
• Infusion therapies

Pro Tip: Many practices check authorization requirements at the time of scheduling. This prevents surprise delays later.

STEP 2: Gather Required Documentation

Essential Information to Have Ready:

Patient Information:
- Full legal name
- Date of birth
- Insurance ID number (front of card)
- Group number (back of card)
- Effective dates of coverage
- Any secondary insurance

Provider Information:
- National Provider ID (NPI)
- Practice contact information
- Treating physician name and credentials
- Specialist performing procedure (if different from referring provider)

Clinical Information:
- Diagnosis code (ICD-10)
- Procedure code (CPT) or medication name/NDC
- Clinical indication (why procedure is medically necessary)
- Relevant clinical findings (test results, measurements, etc.)
- Medications already tried (for medication auth)
- Treatment history relevant to request
- Expected date of service

Documentation Requirements by Payer:

Most payers require some combination of:

• Patient demographics and insurance verification
• Provider and facility information
• Diagnosis and procedure codes
• Clinical narrative explaining medical necessity
• Relevant lab results or imaging
• Previous treatment attempts (especially for medications)
• Clinical guidelines supporting procedure
• Physician's statement regarding urgency

STEP 3: Submit the Prior Authorization Request

Submission Methods (In Order of Speed):

1. Electronic Prior Authorization (ePA) - FASTEST

• Integrated into practice management system
• Automated response in 5-60 minutes for many payers
• Highest adoption with major payers
• Most efficient method

2. Online Payer Portals - MODERATE SPEED

• Direct submission through insurance company website
• 24-48 hour turnaround typical
• Can track status online
• May require account setup

3. Phone/Telephone - MODERATE TO SLOW

• Call insurance authorization department
• Live person can ask clarifying questions
• Verbal approval given, followed by written confirmation
• 30 minutes to several hours for approval
• Can be inefficient if transferred between departments

4. Fax - SLOW

• Traditional method still used by many payers
• Cover sheet with specific patient/procedure info
• 2-5 business days typical turnaround
• Difficult to track status
• May require follow-up call

5. Mail - SLOWEST (Not Recommended)

• Rarely used due to delays
• Can take 5-10 business days
• No tracking ability
• Only used when other methods unavailable

Best Practice: Use electronic submission (ePA or online portal) for non-urgent authorizations. Phone for urgent cases.

STEP 4: Track the Authorization Request

Tracking Process:

Submission Date: [Date]
Payer: [Insurance Company]
Authorization Reference Number: [#]
Expected Decision Date: [Date + 3-5 business days]

Status Check Timeline:
- Day 1: Confirm receipt with payer
- Day 2-3: Check status via portal or call
- Day 4-5: If no decision, escalate to supervisor
- Day 6+: If still pending, file complaint with state insurance commissioner

What You're Looking For:

• Pending: Request under review
• More Information Needed: Submit additional documentation
• Approved: Authorization granted (get authorization number!)
• Approved with Conditions: Coverage limited (review conditions)
• Denied: Not approved (note reason for appeal)

Critical: Write down the authorization number. You'll need this to submit claims.

STEP 5: Receive and Document the Authorization

What You'll Receive:

Authorization Letter Will Include:

• Patient name and ID number
• Authorization number (unique identifier)
• Procedure/service authorized
• Dates of authorization (valid dates)
• Any conditions or limitations
• Provider/facility authorized to deliver service
• Number of visits/treatments authorized (if applicable)
• Any preconditions required before service

Example Authorization:

AUTHORIZATION NOTICE

Patient: John Smith | ID: 123456789 | DOB: 01/15/1965

Authorization #: PA-2024-789456
Service Authorized: MRI Brain
CPT Code: 70553
Diagnosis: Rule out intracranial mass
Authorized Facility: Community Medical Center
Authorized Date Range: 10/27/2024 - 11/27/2024
Status: APPROVED
Conditions: Must be performed at in-network facility
Effective Date of Authorization: 10/27/2024

This authorization does not guarantee payment.
Verify all patient eligibility and benefits at time of service.

Proper Documentation:

• Store authorization letter in patient's medical record
• Add copy to billing file
• Reference authorization number in all claims
• Note authorization expiration date (don't exceed it)
• Follow any conditions/limitations listed

Important: Authorization means the service is medically necessary and covered, but doesn't guarantee payment if benefits lapse or other issues arise.

STEP 6: Provide the Service and Bill Appropriately

Service Delivery:

• Confirm patient still has coverage before service
• Schedule service within authorized dates
• Ensure service delivered by authorized provider/facility
• Use exact codes from authorization

Billing Process:

• Include authorization number on claim
• Use diagnosis and procedure codes from authorization
• Bill the authorized number of visits/units
• Submit claim within timely filing deadline

Claim Submission Tips:

• Always reference authorization number on claim
• If authorization number missing, payer may deny
• Some payers require specific claim format codes
• Verify coverage hasn't changed since authorization

---

Prior Authorization Approval Times by Payer and Procedure Type

Standard Approval Timelines

Non-Urgent Authorizations:

• ePA (Electronic): 5 minutes to 2 hours
• Online portals: 24-48 hours
• Phone requests: 2-4 hours to next business day
• Fax/mail: 3-5 business days

Urgent/Expedited Authorizations:

• ePA: 15-60 minutes
• Phone: 1-4 hours
• Online: 4-12 hours
• Overall expedited standard: 72 hours

Emergency Authorizations:

• Provided retroactively after emergency care
• Billing submission is authorization method
• No advance approval possible
• Review occurs after care delivered

Approval Times by Major Insurance Companies

Medicare Advantage Plans:

• Standard: 3-5 business days
• Urgent: 72 hours
• ePA: Usually same day

Aetna:

• Standard: 3-5 business days
• Urgent: 24-48 hours
• ePA available: Yes

Anthem/Blue Cross Blue Shield:

• Standard: 2-5 business days
• Urgent: 24-48 hours
• ePA available: Yes (for growing list of services)

Cigna:

• Standard: 3-5 business days
• Urgent: 24-48 hours
• ePA available: Yes

Humana:

• Standard: 2-5 business days
• Urgent: 24-48 hours
• ePA available: Limited

United Healthcare:

• Standard: 1-3 business days
• Urgent: 24 hours
• ePA available: Yes (most comprehensive)

Regional/Smaller Plans:

• Standard: 3-10 business days
• Often slower than national plans
• Limited or no ePA capability
• Phone contact often necessary

Approval Times by Procedure Type

Imaging Studies:

• Routine (X-ray, ultrasound): 24-48 hours
• Advanced (MRI, CT): 2-3 business days
• Complex (PET, specialized imaging): 3-5 business days

Surgical Procedures:

• Routine (simple orthopedic): 2-3 business days
• Complex (cardiac, neuro): 3-5 business days
• Emergent: Same day (phone expedited)

Mental Health/Behavioral Health:

• Initial authorization: 2-3 business days
• Continued care: 1-2 business days
• Therapy sessions: 5-10 business days (bulk approvals)

Physical Therapy/Rehabilitation:

• Initial authorization: 2-3 business days
• Ongoing (routine renewal): 1-2 business days

Medications:

• Standard: 1-3 business days
• Non-formulary: 2-5 business days
• Specialty medications: 3-5 business days

Durable Medical Equipment (DME):

• Standard: 3-5 business days
• Urgent: 24-48 hours

Home Health:

• Initial authorization: 2-3 business days
• Ongoing: 1-2 business days

---

Common Procedures Requiring Prior Authorization

High-Frequency Prior Authorization Requirements

These procedures commonly require authorization across most insurance plans:

Imaging and Diagnostic Procedures

Cardiac Imaging:

• Stress tests (exercise, pharmacologic, imaging)
• Echocardiograms (especially follow-up)
• Cardiac catheterization
• Coronary angiography

Neuroimaging:

• MRI brain/spine
• CT brain/spine
• PET scans
• Advanced neuroimaging

Orthopedic Imaging:

• MRI (knee, shoulder, spine most common)
• Advanced imaging of joints
• Pre-surgical imaging

Abdominal Imaging:

• CT abdomen/pelvis
• Abdominal ultrasound (sometimes)
• Specialized abdominal imaging

Surgical Procedures

Orthopedic Surgery:

• Joint replacement (hip, knee)
• Shoulder surgery (rotator cuff repair, etc.)
• Spinal surgery
• Arthroscopic procedures
• ACL reconstruction

Cardiac Surgery:

• Bypass surgery
• Valve replacement
• Cardiac device implantation
• Ablation procedures

Neurological Surgery:

• Spinal fusion
• Tumor resection
• Movement disorder surgery
• Vascular interventions

General Surgery:

• Bariatric surgery (weight loss)
• Gastric bypass
• Laparoscopic procedures (sometimes)

Mental Health and Behavioral Health Services

Very High Prior Auth Rates (15-20%):

• Inpatient psychiatric hospitalization
• Intensive outpatient programs (IOP)
• Partial hospitalization programs (PHP)
• Residential treatment
• Specialized therapies

Moderate Prior Auth Rates (5-10%):

• Individual psychotherapy (ongoing)
• Psychiatric medications (especially new agents)
• Psychological testing
• Group therapy

Physical Therapy and Rehabilitation

Rehabilitation Services:

• Inpatient rehabilitation
• Skilled nursing facility
• Home health (often requires auth)
• Intensive physical therapy (high-frequency)

Occupational/Speech Therapy:

• Initial authorization (usually required)
• Extended therapy beyond standard protocols
• Ongoing therapy beyond medical necessity parameters

Medications and Biologics

High Authorization Rates:

• Specialty medications (biologics, injectables)
• Non-formulary medications
• Off-label use of medications
• Expensive medications
• Controlled substances (sometimes)

Examples:

• Infusion therapies (biologics)
• Injectable medications (humira, enbrel, etc.)
• Oral specialty medications (cancer, hepatitis, etc.)
• Hormone replacement therapy
• Sleep medications (some plans)

Durable Medical Equipment

Frequently Authorized:

• Power wheelchairs
• Continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP) machines
• Oxygen therapy equipment
• Ostomy supplies (initial)
• Diabetic supplies (initial and ongoing)

Additional Services

Home Health:

• Initial authorization common
• Ongoing care authorization
• Specific number of visits authorized

DME Rentals:

• Hospital beds
• Lift equipment
• Specialized equipment

Specialty Procedures:

• Dialysis (initial setup)
• Infusion services
• Genetic testing (sometimes)

---

Prior Authorization Denial and Appeal Process

Understanding Prior Authorization Denials

Denial Rate by Procedure Type:

Service Type	Denial Rate	Common Reasons
Advanced Imaging (MRI, CT)	5-8%	Medical necessity questionable
Surgical Procedures	8-12%	Not meeting medical criteria
Specialty Medications	10-15%	Non-formulary, tried alternatives
Mental Health	15-20%	Medical necessity, frequency limits
Physical Therapy	8-10%	Frequency exceeds guidelines
Durable Equipment	5-8%	Rental vs. purchase, frequency

Common Denial Reasons

1. Lack of Medical Necessity

• Procedure doesn't meet clinical criteria
• Diagnosis doesn't support procedure
• Alternative treatment should be tried first
• Not meeting treatment guidelines

2. Policy Exclusion

• Service explicitly excluded from plan
• Cosmetic procedures
• Experimental treatments
• Non-covered diagnoses

3. Frequency Limitations Exceeded

• More therapy visits requested than allowed
• Imaging ordered too frequently
• Medication refilled before allowed
• Services bundled as single authorization

4. Preconditions Not Met

• Failed less expensive treatment first
• Didn't try generic medication before brand
• Conservative treatment not attempted
• Required documentation missing

5. Out-of-Network Provider

• Service requested from non-network provider
• No authorization for specific facility
• Referred to wrong provider type
• Network change since authorization

6. Incomplete or Incorrect Information

• Missing clinical documentation
• Wrong diagnosis codes
• Incomplete patient information
• Outdated authorization reference

Appealing a Prior Authorization Denial

Appeal Process Timeline:

Step 1: Receive Denial Notice
- Date received: [Date]
- Reason for denial: [Reason]
- Appeal deadline: Typically 30-60 days from denial date

Step 2: Determine Appeal Strategy
- Can additional information help? (medical necessity appeal)
- Is clinical evidence available? (peer-reviewed data)
- Should provider call for phone appeal?

Step 3: Prepare Appeal Documentation
- Compile clinical evidence
- Get physician statement
- Gather medical guidelines
- Document alternative treatments tried
- Time: 2-5 days

Step 4: Submit Appeal
- Via phone (expedited)
- Via mail (standard)
- Via online portal (if available)
- Time: 1-3 business days for submission

Step 5: Monitor Appeal Status
- Confirmation of receipt
- Appeal review in progress
- Appeal decision notification
- Time: 30-90 days for resolution

Step 6: Next Steps if Still Denied
- Request second opinion review
- File external appeal (independent reviewer)
- Contact state insurance commissioner
- Prepare for financial liability

First-Level Appeal (Internal Review)

Effective First-Level Appeals Include:

1. Clinical Evidence Packet:

• Recent lab results supporting medical necessity
• Imaging or diagnostic test results
• Medical literature supporting procedure
• Professional society guidelines
• Peer-reviewed articles

2. Physician Statement:

• Letter explaining medical necessity
• Why alternative treatments inadequate
• Why procedure is appropriate for diagnosis
• Expected clinical outcomes
• Time-sensitive nature (if applicable)

3. Treatment History:

• Previous conservative treatments attempted
• Medications tried (for medication denials)
• Therapy sessions completed (for more sessions)
• Results of previous treatments
• Why additional intervention needed

4. Documentation Corrections:

• If denial due to incomplete info, provide missing elements
• Clarify any misunderstood information
• Correct any errors in original request
• Reference any changes since original request

Appeal Success Rate:

• Overall: 30-50% of appeals successful
• Clinical evidence provided: 50-70%
• Physician call supporting appeal: 60-75%
• Professional guidelines cited: 40-60%

Second-Level Appeal (External Review)

When to Request:

• First appeal denied
• Clinical evidence substantial but still denied
• Treatment time-sensitive
• Want independent review

Process:

• Request external/independent review
• Typically assigned to different reviewer
• Takes 20-30 days for resolution
• Cost: Usually no additional cost (covered by payer)

What External Reviewers Do:

• Conduct independent clinical review
• Evaluate medical necessity
• Compare to clinical guidelines
• Check for policy violations
• Make recommendation to payer

External Review Success Rate:

• Higher than internal appeal (50-70%)
• Clinical evidence key to success
• Peer expert reviewers often more flexible

Filing a Complaint with State Insurance Commissioner

When to File:

• Multiple appeals denied without clear reason
• Pattern of inappropriate denials
• Payer not following state law requirements
• Improper appeal process
• Egregious denial of clearly necessary care

Filing Process:

• Gather documentation of denial(s)
• State insurance commissioner contact info
• File formal complaint
• Include copies of all correspondence
• Processing takes 30-60 days

This Should Trigger:

• Investigation by state
• Payer response required
• State assessment
• Possible fines if payer violated rules
• Public record of complaint

---

Strategies to Reduce Prior Authorization Delays

Strategy 1: Use Electronic Prior Authorization (ePA)

What is ePA? Electronic prior authorization streamlines the submission and decision process through automated systems.

How ePA Works:

1. Integrated into practice management system
2. Automated documentation validation
3. Payer receives request electronically
4. Criteria-based automated decision (when possible)
5. Real-time response (minutes to hours)
6. Electronic authorization number issued

Benefits:

• Fastest approval method (5 minutes to 2 hours typical)
• Reduced administrative time
• Higher success rates
• No phone calls or faxes
• Tracks all submissions
• Electronic audit trail

Current ePA Adoption:

• Major insurers: 40-60% of authorizations ePA-capable
• Growing rapidly (2-3x annual growth)
• Currently available for common procedures
• Limited for rare/complex procedures

How to Implement ePA:

1. Verify billing software supports ePA
2. Enroll with each insurance payer
3. Get ePA credentials from each payer
4. Configure integration in your system
5. Train staff on ePA process
6. Monitor approval rates and adjust

Strategy 2: Create an Authorization Matrix

What is an Authorization Matrix? A reference document showing which services require prior authorization for each payer.

Matrix Elements:

Payer: Anthem Blue Cross
Patient Type: Commercial (non-HMO)

Service Category | Procedure | Requires Auth? | Turnaround | Requirements
─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
Imaging         | Routine X-ray | No | N/A | N/A
Imaging         | MRI Brain | Yes | 2-3 days | ICD-10 + clinical note
Imaging         | CT Abdomen | Yes | 2-3 days | ICD-10 + clinical note
Surgery         | Knee arthroscopy | Yes | 3-5 days | ICD-10 + H&P
Surgery         | Hip replacement | Yes | 3-5 days | ICD-10 + H&P
PT/OT           | Initial PT eval | No | N/A | N/A
PT/OT           | >12 PT visits | Yes | 2-3 days | Clinical progress notes

Matrix Benefits:

• Quick reference for staff
• Reduces phone calls to verify
• Prevents missed authorizations
• Helps with scheduling
• Supports cost estimations to patients

Creating Your Matrix:

1. List top 50 procedures/services by volume
2. For each payer, verify authorization requirement
3. Document required documentation
4. Note standard turnaround time
5. Update quarterly as payers change

Strategy 3: Request Authorizations at Time of Scheduling

Pre-Service Verification Workflow:

Step 1: Patient Calls for Appointment
- Confirm insurance information
- Collect current insurance details

Step 2: Verify Benefits
- Confirm coverage active
- Check deductible status
- Verify network status

Step 3: Check Authorization Requirement
- Determine if authorization needed
- Check authorization matrix
- Call payer if unsure

Step 4: Request Authorization Immediately
- Submit auth request same day
- Use ePA if available
- Set follow-up reminder
- Note in appointment details

Step 5: Confirm Before Appointment
- Verify authorization received
- Note auth number in chart
- Call patient to confirm

Step 6: Day of Service
- Verify coverage still active
- Confirm no changes since auth request
- Proceed with service

Benefits:

• Catches authorization needs early
• Allows time for approval
• Prevents scheduling conflicts
• Reduces delays day-of-service

Strategy 4: Optimize Documentation for Authorizations

Submit Complete Information First Time:

Essential Elements Checklist:

□ Patient Name and DOB
□ Insurance ID and Group Number
□ Diagnosis Code (ICD-10) - be specific
□ Procedure Code (CPT or medication name)
□ Clinical Indication (brief explanation of why medically necessary)
□ Relevant Lab/Test Results (most recent)
□ Previous Treatment History (what's been tried)
□ Medications Currently Taking (for medication auth)
□ Provider Information (NPI, license #)
□ Date of Service Requested
□ Urgency Level (routine, urgent, emergent)
□ Any Special Circumstances

Common Documentation Mistakes That Delay Approval:

• Missing diagnosis specificity
• No clinical findings to support necessity
• Missing prior treatment attempts
• Incomplete patient demographics
• Wrong procedure codes
• Vague clinical indication

Prevention:

• Create pre-populated forms by payer
• Use templates for common authorizations
• Train staff on required elements
• Use checklist before submission
• Review for completeness

Strategy 5: Build Relationships with Payer Representatives

Payer Account Management:

Key Activities:

1. Identify your payer account representative

2. Schedule quarterly meetings to discuss:

   • Common denial reasons
   • Policy changes coming
   • Optimization opportunities
   • Outstanding authorization issues

3. During meetings:

   • Ask about ePA implementation timeline
   • Clarify ambiguous policies
   • Discuss expedited approval options
   • Share denial data for feedback

4. Between meetings:

   • Send account rep denial trends you're seeing
   • Ask for guidance on reducing denials
   • Report process problems
   • Suggest workflow improvements

Benefits:

• Faster turnaround for problem authorizations
• Advance notice of policy changes
• Better understanding of requirements
• Relationship expedites urgent cases
• Advocacy for reasonable timelines

Strategy 6: Train Staff on Prior Authorization Process

Staff Training Program:

Who Needs Training:

• Schedulers (front desk)
• Insurance verification staff
• Billing staff
• Clinical staff (nurses, therapists)
• Providers (understanding their role)

Training Topics:

1. Prior authorization basics (what/why)
2. Identification of auth-required services
3. Submission methods and timelines
4. Documentation requirements
5. ePA process (if implemented)
6. Tracking and follow-up
7. Appeal process
8. Patient communication

Training Materials:

• Authorization matrix (by payer)
• Step-by-step process flowchart
• Checklist for submissions
• FAQs specific to your payers
• Problem-solving scenarios
• Quarterly updates on changes

Measurement:

• Track authorization errors rate
• Monitor approval times
• Measure compliance with checklists
• Survey staff on knowledge
• Identify training gaps

Strategy 7: Communicate with Patients Proactively

Patient Communication Protocol:

Before Service:

• Inform patient that authorization required
• Explain what it is and why
• Estimate approval timeline
• Provide cost estimate (once approved)
• Explain patient's financial responsibility
• Answer questions about process

During Authorization Process:

• Provide authorization reference number
• Set expectation for timeline
• Let patient know when approved
• Confirm no coverage changes needed

If Delayed:

• Explain delay and expected resolution date
• Offer to escalate to payer
• Discuss potential alternatives
• Keep updated on status

If Denied:

• Explain reason for denial
• Discuss appeal process
• Outline alternative options
• Clarify patient's financial responsibility

Benefits:

• Patients more understanding of delays
• Fewer patient complaints
• Increased trust in your practice
• Reduced no-shows (when patients know ahead)

Strategy 8: Implement Backup Plans for Denials

When Authorization Denied:

Immediate Actions:

1. Document denial reason
2. Assess appeal viability
3. Determine alternatives:
   • Appeal the denial
   • Proceed with alternative treatment
   • Request external review
   • Pursue out-of-pocket option
4. Communicate options to patient
5. Decide on next steps

For Appealable Denials:

• Gather supporting clinical evidence (1-2 days)
• Prepare physician letter (1 day)
• Submit appeal (1 day)
• Track appeal status (30-60 days resolution)

For Non-Appealable Denials:

• Discuss alternatives with patient
• Estimate out-of-pocket costs if proceeding
• Get written consent if patient pays out-of-pocket
• Proceed with alternate approved treatment

For Time-Sensitive Cases:

• Request expedited appeal (24-48 hours)
• Phone the payer (discuss urgency)
• File complaint with state insurance commissioner
• Proceed with treatment and bill patient (with consent)
• Seek reimbursement after resolution

---

Electronic Prior Authorization (ePA) Explained

What is Electronic Prior Authorization?

ePA Definition: Electronic prior authorization is the automated submission and processing of prior authorization requests through standardized electronic systems, replacing manual phone and fax submissions.

ePA Workflow:

1. Clinician orders service in EHR
2. System recognizes auth needed
3. Clinical documentation auto-populated
4. Submitted to payer via ePA system
5. Payer's system validates information
6. If complete, automated decision or medical review
7. Response sent back electronically
8. Authorization number issued
9. All documented in patient record

Timeline Comparison:

Method	Submission	Processing	Response	Total Time
ePA	Instant	5-60 min	Real-time	5 min-1 hour
Online Portal	5-10 min	24 hours	Email	24-48 hours
Phone	15-20 min	1-4 hours	Verbal	2-24 hours
Fax	5 min	24-72 hours	Fax/phone	3-5 days

Current ePA Implementation

Payers Offering ePA (As of 2024):

Fully Implemented:

• United Healthcare (most comprehensive)
• Aetna
• Anthem/Blue Cross Blue Shield (expanding)
• Cigna (expanding)

Partial Implementation:

• Humana (growing)
• Medicare Advantage plans (varies)
• Regional/smaller plans (growing)

Coverage Percentage:

• Overall: ~40-50% of prior authorizations ePA-capable
• Growth: 20-30% annual growth
• Goal: 100% of authorizations ePA-capable within 5 years

ePA-Ready Procedures (Current):

• Advanced imaging (MRI, CT - most payers)
• Orthopedic procedures (knee surgery, etc.)
• Many specialty medications
• Physical therapy
• DME (growing)

How to Implement ePA in Your Practice

Implementation Steps:

Step 1: Assess Your Current System (1 week)

• Evaluate practice management software vendor
• Check which payers they support for ePA
• Determine integration capability
• Identify current workflow gaps

Step 2: Select ePA Solution (1-2 weeks)

• Option A: Use PMS built-in ePA
• Option B: Standalone ePA platform
• Option C: Health information exchange (HIE)
• Evaluate costs and features

Step 3: Enroll with Payers (2-4 weeks)

• Contact each payer for ePA enrollment
• Get ePA credentials and access
• Set up account credentials
• Test connectivity

Step 4: Configure Your System (2-3 weeks)

• Map your procedure codes to payer requirements
• Set up auth requirements in PMS
• Create ePA templates for common procedures
• Configure automatic population of data

Step 5: Staff Training (1 week)

• Train on new workflow
• Practice with test cases
• Establish escalation procedures
• Create backup procedures

Step 6: Go Live with Pilot (1-2 weeks)

• Start with one procedure type
• Monitor success rates
• Get feedback from staff
• Troubleshoot issues

Step 7: Expand Rollout (2-4 weeks)

• Add more payers
• Add more procedure types
• Monitor metrics
• Optimize workflow

Total Implementation: 8-12 weeks

ePA Benefits and Challenges

Benefits:

• Fastest approval method (minutes vs. days)
• Reduced staff time (5-10 min vs. 30 min)
• Higher completion rates (fewer missing items)
• Better tracking and audit trail
• Fewer denials (pre-validated)
• Improved patient experience

Challenges:

• Initial implementation costs ($10,000-50,000)
• Requires system integration
• Limited payer adoption (still growing)
• Learning curve for staff
• Technical issues/troubleshooting
• Changes require updates

ROI Calculation:

Typical Practice (15 providers, 100 authorizations/month):

Cost:
- Implementation: $20,000 (one-time)
- Annual software: $5,000
- Staff training: $2,000
Total Year 1: $27,000

Benefit:
- Time savings: 100 auth/month × 20 min savings × 12 months
  = 2,000 hours/year × $35/hour = $70,000

- Approval rate improvement: 5 more approvals/month
  (due to completeness) × $5,000 avg value = $300,000/year

- Reduced denials: 10 fewer denials/month due to errors
  = $60,000/year

Total Year 1 Benefit: $430,000
ROI Year 1: 1,489%
Payback Period: ~1 month

---

Prior Authorization Requirements by Specialty

Cardiology

High Prior Auth Requirement Rate: 40-60%

Procedures Requiring Auth:

• Stress tests (exercise, pharmacologic, imaging)
• Cardiac catheterization
• Coronary angiography
• Echocardiograms (follow-up, 2D, 3D, etc.)
• Electrophysiology studies
• Ablation procedures
• ICD/pacemaker implantation
• Cardiac surgery (CABG, valve replacement)

Specialty Challenges:

• High-cost procedures (often $10,000+)
• High denial rates (10-15%)
• Urgent cases requiring expedited approval
• Multiple payers with different criteria
• Time-sensitive nature (cardiac conditions)

Success Strategies:

• Pre-certification at first office visit
• Rapid submission for urgent cases
• Build relationships with cardiology-focused payer reps
• Maintain cardiology-specific auth matrix
• Train cardiology staff on authorization process

Orthopedic Surgery

High Prior Auth Requirement Rate: 50-70%

Procedures Requiring Auth:

• Joint replacement (hip, knee, shoulder, ankle)
• Arthroscopic procedures (scope, meniscus, rotator cuff)
• Spinal fusion
• ACL reconstruction
• Fracture surgery
• Complex orthopedic procedures
• Advanced imaging (MRI, advanced imaging)

Specialty Challenges:

• High cost procedures (joint replacement $30,000+)
• Many elective procedures (lower priority)
• Prior conservative treatment requirement
• Medical necessity scrutiny (surgery vs. physical therapy)
• Frequency limits (joint replacement typically 1 per lifetime)

Success Strategies:

• Document conservative treatment attempts
• MRI results supporting surgical necessity
• Orthopedic surgeon referral documentation
• Patient's failed physical therapy evidence
• Maintain orthopedic-specific auth matrix

Radiology and Diagnostic Imaging

High Prior Auth Requirement Rate: 30-50%

Exams Requiring Auth:

• MRI (brain, spine, extremity, abdomen)
• CT (especially CT abdomen/pelvis)
• Advanced imaging (PET, SPECT)
• Repeated imaging (same body part within short timeframe)
• Specialized imaging (cardiac CT, dynamic imaging)

Specialty Challenges:

• Rapid utilization (imaging ordered frequently)
• Appropriate use criteria (AUC) requirements
• Limited repeat imaging (same site)
• Prior imaging restrictions
• Clinical judgment questions

Success Strategies:

• Use appropriate use criteria (AUC) in ordering
• Document clinical findings supporting imaging need
• Reference prior imaging when available
• Justify follow-up imaging with clinical evidence
• Use ePA for imaging authorizations

Mental Health and Behavioral Health

Highest Prior Auth Requirement Rate: 60-80%

Services Requiring Auth:

• Inpatient psychiatric hospitalization
• Intensive outpatient programs (IOP)
• Partial hospitalization (PHP)
• Residential treatment
• Specialized therapies
• Continued outpatient therapy (beyond routine limits)
• Psychiatric medications (specialized)

Specialty Challenges:

• Very high denial rates (15-20%)
• Medical necessity scrutiny
• Frequency limits (sessions per year/month)
• Medical criteria requirements (acuity level)
• Prior authorization requirement intensity

Success Strategies:

• Document medical necessity thoroughly
• Use mental health screening tools (PHQ-9, GAD-7)
• Submit brief psychosocial assessment
• Justify continued treatment with clinical progress
• Know payer's specific mental health policies

Gastroenterology

Moderate Prior Auth Requirement Rate: 20-40%

Procedures Requiring Auth:

• Upper endoscopy (sometimes for non-screening)
• Colonoscopy (sometimes for non-screening)
• ERCP (endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography)
• Advanced GI procedures
• Motility studies
• Advanced imaging

Specialty Challenges:

• Appropriate use criteria (screening vs. diagnostic)
• Frequency limits (colonoscopy every 10 years)
• Prior test requirement (consider recent endoscopy)
• Indication specificity

Success Strategies:

• Document indication clearly (symptoms, risk factors)
• Note any prior imaging/endoscopy with dates
• Distinguish screening from diagnostic indication

---

The Impact of Prior Authorization on Patient Care

How Prior Authorization Affects Treatment Outcomes

Positive Impacts:

• Prevents unnecessary procedures
• Guides appropriate treatment selection
• Encourages evidence-based medicine
• Supports conservative approaches when appropriate
• Encourages multidisciplinary discussion

Negative Impacts:

• Treatment delays causing deterioration
• Patient deferral of needed care (cost anxiety)
• Clinical urgency not accommodated
• Increased provider burnout (administrative burden)
• Preventable complications from delayed care

Clinical Delays from Prior Authorization

Time Lost to Authorization:

• Average delay: 3-7 days (non-urgent)
• Urgent/expedited: 24-72 hours
• Some cases delayed 2-4 weeks

Clinical Impact by Condition:

Cardiac Conditions:

• Delay in catheterization: Increased MI risk
• Delay in cardiac surgery: Disease progression
• Delay in medication: Symptom worsening

Cancer Treatment:

• Delay in surgery: Disease progression
• Delay in chemotherapy: Tumor growth
• Delay in radiation: Reduced efficacy

Mental Health Crisis:

• Delay in inpatient admission: Risk of harm
• Delay in intensive outpatient program: Relapse risk
• Delay in medication: Symptom escalation

Orthopedic Conditions:

• Delay in surgery: Deconditioning, disability
• Delay in therapy: Limited improvement potential
• Delay in treatment: Chronic pain development

Patient Satisfaction and Financial Impact

Patient Burden:

• 45% of patients report anxiety about authorization process
• 30% delay or skip treatments due to auth uncertainty
• 25% report out-of-pocket costs due to auth delays
• 40% cite authorization as barrier to care access

Financial Impact:

• Average patient out-of-pocket cost: $500-$2,000 per authorization delay
• Emergency department visits from delayed care: $1,000-$5,000
• Hospitalization from complications: $5,000-$50,000
• Lost productivity from delayed care: $1,000-$10,000

Provider Burden and Burnout

Administrative Time:

• Average 20-30 minutes per authorization
• Average 2-3 hours per denial appeal
• 10% of clinical staff time devoted to authorizations
• Opportunity cost: Time away from patient care

Burnout Impact:

• 60% of providers cite prior auth as major stressor
• 30% cite as reason considering leaving practice
• Administrative burden cited as top burnout factor
• Mental health providers especially impacted

---

The Future of Prior Authorization

Current Reform Efforts

Legislative Advocacy:

• CMS working on automation requirements
• State legislatures passing time-limit requirements
• Medical associations pushing for ePA mandates
• Patient advocates calling for reform

CMS Initiatives (2024-2026):

• Proposed ePA requirements for Medicare Advantage
• Faster decision timelines (24 hours for urgent)
• Transparent criteria for medical necessity
• Reduced documentation requirements
• Payer accountability measures

Insurance Industry Response:

• Increased ePA implementation
• Faster turnaround times
• Simplified authorization processes
• More transparent criteria

Emerging Technologies

AI and Machine Learning:

• Automated prior authorization decisions
• Predictive analytics (which cases will deny)
• Natural language processing (auto-populate documentation)
• Robotic process automation (workflow optimization)

Blockchain and Interoperability:

• Standardized authorization data exchange
• Real-time eligibility and authorization verification
• Reduced duplicate authorizations
• Improved data security

Integration with EHRs:

• Seamless authorization within clinical workflow
• Pop-up alerts when authorization needed
• Pre-populated request forms
• Real-time decision support

Predicted Changes by 2026

More Automation:

• 50-70% of authorizations automated (vs. 40% today)
• ePA available for 80%+ of services
• AI-assisted decision making

Faster Timelines:

• 24-hour standard for most non-urgent
• 4-hour for urgent cases
• Same-day emergency approvals

Better Integration:

• Deeper EHR integration
• Health information exchange integration
• Minimal manual data entry required

Increased Transparency:

• Clear authorization criteria published
• Appeal success rates disclosed
• Payer performance metrics public
• Patient-friendly explanation of decisions

---

Prior Authorization Checklist for Submissions

Pre-Authorization Checklist

Use this checklist to ensure complete submissions:

PRIOR AUTHORIZATION SUBMISSION CHECKLIST

PATIENT INFORMATION
☐ Patient full legal name
☐ Date of birth (MM/DD/YYYY)
☐ Insurance ID number
☐ Group/Policy number
☐ Effective dates of coverage
☐ Secondary insurance (if applicable)

PROVIDER INFORMATION
☐ Referring provider name and NPI
☐ Referring provider contact information
☐ Treating provider/specialist name and NPI
☐ Facility name and location (if applicable)
☐ Facility contact information

CLINICAL INFORMATION
☐ Diagnosis code(s) (ICD-10 - be specific)
☐ Procedure code (CPT) or medication name/NDC
☐ Date of service requested
☐ Clinical indication (why procedure is medically necessary)
☐ Relevant clinical findings (test results, measurements)
☐ Functional limitations (if applicable)
☐ Current symptoms
☐ Previous treatments attempted
☐ Medications currently taking (for med auth)
☐ Allergies documented
☐ Comorbid conditions affecting treatment

MEDICAL NECESSITY DOCUMENTATION
☐ Clinical narrative (2-3 sentences explaining necessity)
☐ Relevant test/lab results
☐ Imaging results (if applicable)
☐ Specialist recommendation (if from referral)
☐ Treatment failure documentation (if required)
☐ Clinical guidelines supporting procedure
☐ Patient's failed medication trial (for medication auth)

AUTHORIZATION REQUEST DETAILS
☐ Type of request (new, continuation, expedited)
☐ Urgency level (routine, urgent, emergent)
☐ Number of visits/units requested
☐ Expected date of service
☐ Facility/location of service
☐ Requested authorization duration

CONTACT INFORMATION
☐ Contact person completing request
☐ Contact phone number
☐ Contact email
☐ Fax number (if faxing response)
☐ Preferred method of response (ePA, fax, email, phone)

SUBMISSION METHOD
☐ Selected submission method:
  ☐ ePA (fastest - recommended)
  ☐ Online portal
  ☐ Phone
  ☐ Fax
  ☐ Mail

FOLLOW-UP PLAN
☐ Confirmation of receipt (within 1-2 business days)
☐ Follow-up call if no response by [date]
☐ Escalation plan if delayed beyond [timeframe]
☐ Documentation of authorization number received

---

Frequently Asked Questions About Prior Authorization

Q: What's the difference between prior authorization and a referral?

A: Referral is when your primary care doctor sends you to a specialist. It's often required for HMO plans to receive specialist care.

Prior authorization is when the insurance company approves a specific service/procedure before it's provided.

You may need both: a referral to see the specialist AND prior authorization for the specialist's proposed procedure.

Q: Does prior authorization guarantee payment?

A: No. Prior authorization means:

• The service is medically necessary
• The service is covered by the plan
• The procedure meets authorization criteria

But payment is NOT guaranteed if:

• Patient's coverage lapses between authorization and service
• Patient's benefits change
• Coding on the claim differs from authorization
• Other policy violations occur

Always verify coverage immediately before the service.

Q: How long is a prior authorization valid?

A: Validity varies by payer and service:

• Standard: 30-60 days from authorization date
• Extended care: 90-180 days for ongoing services
• Some authorizations: 1 year for ongoing conditions

Always check the authorization letter for expiration date. Don't perform services after the authorization expires without requesting renewal.

Q: What if I perform a service without prior authorization?

A: Consequences vary:

• Non-required service: No problem, bill normally
• Required but not obtained: Claim will be denied
  • You may be responsible for bill (check contract)
  • Patient may owe balance (review balance billing rules)
  • Resubmit with retroactive authorization request (40% success rate)
• Emergencies: Perform care, submit for retroactive authorization

Prevention: Always verify authorization status before scheduling.

Q: Can I appeal a denied prior authorization?

A: Yes, absolutely. Most denials are appealable.

Appeal Success Rates:

• Overall: 30-50% of appeals successful
• With clinical evidence: 50-70% success
• With physician phone support: 60-75% success

Timeline: Submit appeal within 30-60 days of denial. Don't wait.

Q: How much should I tell a patient about prior authorization?

A: Patient communication should include:

• Explain what prior authorization is (briefly)
• Say authorization is needed for [service]
• Provide timeline: "Usually takes 2-3 days"
• Explain they may be contacted by insurance
• Clarify their cost responsibility
• Provide authorization number once received

Don't: Make them feel like there's a problem or that approval is uncertain (unless it is).

Q: What's the fastest way to get prior authorization?

A: In order of speed:

1. ePA (Electronic): 5 minutes to 2 hours (if available)
2. Phone call: 1-4 hours (expedited)
3. Online portal: 4-12 hours (for urgent)
4. Phone (standard): Next business day
5. Online portal: 24-48 hours
6. Fax: 2-5 business days

Use ePA when available. Call for urgent cases. Avoid fax.

Q: Can I use the same prior authorization for multiple visits?

A: Sometimes. It depends on the authorization:

Single-date authorizations: Cannot be reused (one-time only)

Multi-visit authorizations: Can be used for all authorized visits within date range

• Example: "PT authorization for up to 12 visits between 10/27/24 - 12/27/24"

Always check the authorization letter. If in doubt, request renewal for continued services.

Q: How do I know if ePA is available with my payer?

A: Ways to check:

1. Ask your billing software vendor (do they support ePA?)
2. Call the insurance company's provider line
3. Check the payer's website for ePA information
4. Ask other practices in your specialty
5. Contact your payer's account representative

ePA availability is growing rapidly. Ask about it even if not currently offered.

Q: What's the most common reason for prior authorization denial?

A: #1: Lack of medical necessity (35% of denials)

• Procedure doesn't meet clinical criteria
• Diagnosis doesn't support procedure
• Conservative treatment not attempted first
• Doesn't meet established guidelines

Prevention: Ensure documentation supports medical necessity clearly.

Q: Should I bill the patient while waiting for prior authorization?

A: General rules:

Don't bill until:

• Authorization received AND
• Service already delivered (in some cases)

Bill after service if:

• Authorization received before service
• Verbal authorization confirmed (note confirmation)
• Emergency care (bill, seek retroactive auth)

Check your patient consent form regarding authorization status before service delivery.

Q: What if a patient's coverage lapses after prior authorization is issued?

A: Call the insurance company immediately to determine:

• Whether authorization remains valid despite lapsed coverage
• If patient lost coverage, usually authorization becomes void
• Whether patient can reinstate coverage
• What happens to any services already authorized

Don't assume authorization remains valid. Verify coverage immediately before service.

---

Author Bio

Robert Chen, RN, MBA is a healthcare administration professional with 15+ years of experience managing prior authorization processes across multiple healthcare settings. He has helped hospitals and practices streamline authorization workflows, implement ePA, and reduce authorization-related denials. Robert regularly presents on healthcare administrative operations and works with technology vendors on ePA implementation.

---

Related Articles

• Complete Guide to Medical Billing Denial Codes: 50+ Codes & How to Fix Them
• Medical Billing Outsourcing Cost Guide 2024: Pricing Models, ROI & What to Expect
• Medical Coding Best Practices: 15 Expert Tips for Accuracy & Compliance [2024]
• Medical Billing Denial Rate Benchmarks: What's Normal for Your Specialty

---

Ready to Streamline Your Prior Authorization Process?

Prior authorization doesn't have to be a nightmare. Many practices are managing authorizations efficiently with the right processes and technology.

If your practice struggles with:

• Long authorization approval times
• Frequent authorization denials
• Administrative burden of manual submissions
• Staff time devoted to authorization follow-up
• Patient complaints about authorization delays

Our prior authorization management services can help:

• ePA implementation and support
• Streamlined submission workflows
• Expedited appeal management
• Staff training on best practices
• 24/7 authorization support
• Real-time tracking and reporting

We help practices:

• Reduce authorization approval times by 40-60%
• Decrease denial rates by 30-50%
• Free up staff time for patient care
• Improve patient satisfaction
• Accelerate treatment delivery

Get Your Free Prior Authorization Assessment: We'll analyze your current authorization process to identify:

• Bottlenecks causing delays
• Common denial patterns
• Opportunities for improvement
• ePA implementation feasibility
• Staff training needs

Contact us today for a free prior authorization assessment and discover how professional authorization management can improve your practice's efficiency and patient care.